Asana as a Make Alternative
Structured work management with goals and portfolio reporting. See how it stacks up against Make on pricing, capability and real switching costs.
Overview
Make is an established business software platform, built for ops engineers building branching, data-heavy automations cheaply. Teams searching for a Make alternative usually hit one of two limits: either smaller app directory than zapier, or a workflow that needs structured work management with goals and portfolio reporting. Asana starts at Starter · $10.99/user/mo and is designed for operations and programme teams managing cross-team portfolios, which makes it a credible switch for teams that have outgrown the original fit.
This page compares Asana and Make on the criteria that actually decide a migration: entry pricing and free access, ease of use, native integrations, API availability, collaboration model, AI capabilities, support and verified user ratings. Asana wins 1 of the 6 directly comparable attributes in our structured dataset; the sections below explain where those numbers come from and where Make still has the advantage.
Asana vs Make: core parameters
Ten structured attributes. Highlighted cells indicate the stronger value on a directly comparable row.
| Attribute | AsanaRecommended | Make |
|---|---|---|
| Starting priceEntry paid tier, list price, USD per month unless stated. | Starter · $10.99/user/mo | Core · $9/mo |
| Free planWhether a usable free tier exists, not just a time-limited trial. | Yes | Yes |
| Best for | Operations and programme teams managing cross-team portfolios | Ops engineers building branching, data-heavy automations cheaply |
| Ease of useEditorial 1-5 score based on onboarding friction and UI clarity. | 5.0 / 5 | 4.0 / 5 |
| Native integrationsApproximate connectors listed in the vendor marketplace. | 300 | 2,000 |
| Public API | Yes | Yes |
| Collaboration | Goals, portfolios, workload, approvals, rules and status updates | Shared scenarios, team roles, version history, execution logs |
| AI capabilities | AI teammates for workflow building, summaries and smart status | AI-assisted scenario generation and module configuration |
| Support | Email and chat, priority support on Business and Enterprise | Email and in-app support, priority support on higher tiers |
| G2 ratingPoint-in-time G2 snapshot. Verify on the vendor G2 profile before publishing. | 4.4 / 5 | 4.7 / 5 |
| Next step | Try Asana →Free plan available · Official vendor site · G2 4.4/5 | Compare the incumbent on its own terms before committing to a migration. |
Pricing and ratings are point-in-time snapshots and may change. Always confirm on the vendor site. Editorial ease-of-use scores are our own assessment; G2 ratings are attributed to G2.
Pros & cons, side by side
Asana
AlternativeStructured work management with goals and portfolio reporting
Advantages
- Best-in-class goal-to-task alignment and portfolio visibility
- Clean, calm interface with strong mobile apps
- Mature approval and rule automation
Trade-offs
- No native time tracking and limited built-in docs
- Per-user pricing becomes costly above 50 seats
Make
Visual scenario builder for complex, high-volume workflows
Advantages
- Visual canvas makes routers, iterators and error handlers intuitive
- Operation-based pricing is far cheaper at high volume than Zapier
- Deep HTTP, webhook and data-transformation modules
Trade-offs
- Smaller app directory than Zapier
- Debugging dense scenarios takes practice
Deep analysis: where the difference actually shows up
5 sectionsPricing: Starter · $10.99/user/mo vs Core · $9/mo
Asana starts at $10.99/mo and Make at $9/mo. Make is cheaper at the entry tier, so Asana has to justify a $1.99 monthly premium on capability. Free access differs too: Asana provides a free tier, while Make does. Model your real seat count and required add-ons over three years — headline prices rarely survive that exercise.
Where Asana pulls ahead
Best-in-class goal-to-task alignment and portfolio visibility It also clean, calm interface with strong mobile apps. In the structured comparison, Asana scores 5.0/5 on ease of use against 4.0/5, lists 300 integrations against 2,000, and carries a 4.4/5 G2 rating against 4.7/5. Goals & Portfolios and timeline are the capabilities most often cited by teams making this switch.
Where Make still wins
Visual canvas makes routers, iterators and error handlers intuitive It also operation-based pricing is far cheaper at high volume than Zapier. Its ai-assisted scenario generation and module configuration is a genuine differentiator for ops engineers building branching, data-heavy automations cheaply. The honest caveat for Asana is that no native time tracking and limited built-in docs, and per-user pricing becomes costly above 50 seats. If either of those is a hard constraint in your environment, staying on Make is the lower-risk decision.
Integration surface, API and AI
Asana lists 300+ native integrations and a public API; Make lists 2,000+ and a public API. On collaboration, Asana offers goals, portfolios, workload, approvals, rules and status updates, versus shared scenarios, team roles, version history, execution logs for Make. AI coverage also differs: Asana delivers ai teammates for workflow building, summaries and smart status, while Make focuses on ai-assisted scenario generation and module configuration. For a stack with many connected systems, integration breadth is often the deciding factor, not the feature checklist.
Switching costs and rollout
Moving from Make to Asana is an operational project rather than a software install. Export your data, map custom fields and permissions, rebuild automations, and keep both systems readable for at least one reporting cycle so historical comparisons stay valid. Support differs as well: Asana provides email and chat, priority support on business and enterprise, whereas Make provides email and in-app support, priority support on higher tiers. Start with a single team, freeze further configuration for two weeks, and only then roll out broadly — most failed migrations are process problems, not product problems.
The verdict
Make still wins more of the directly comparable attributes in this matchup (1 of 6 go to Asana), so switching only makes sense if you specifically need best-in-class goal-to-task alignment and portfolio visibility. Asana is a better fit for operations and programme teams managing cross-team portfolios, while Make remains the safer default for ops engineers building branching, data-heavy automations cheaply. If your requirements are mostly generic, the incumbent is the lower-risk choice; if one of the Asana strengths above is decisive, run a short parallel trial before committing.
When switching to Asana makes sense
Concrete triggers that justify a migration away from Make.
- 1Best-in-class goal-to-task alignment and portfolio visibility
- 2Clean, calm interface with strong mobile apps
- 3Mature approval and rule automation
- 4A free tier makes evaluation possible without an upfront commitment
Try Asana
Recommended next step
Start with Asana, keep your current tool for one cycle
Free plan available · Official vendor site · G2 4.4/5
Frequently asked questions
Is Asana a good alternative to Make?
Asana is a strong Make alternative for operations and programme teams managing cross-team portfolios. It starts at Starter · $10.99/user/mo, scores 5.0/5 for ease of use and holds a 4.4/5 G2 rating. Make remains the better fit for ops engineers building branching, data-heavy automations cheaply, so the decision comes down to which workflow dominates your week.
How does Asana pricing compare with Make?
Asana starts at Starter · $10.99/user/mo and Make at Core · $9/mo. Asana costs more at entry, so evaluate it on capability rather than price. Always compare total cost at your real seat count, including paid add-ons and higher tiers.
Does Asana offer a free plan or trial?
Yes. Asana has a free tier with goals & portfolios and a limited feature set, which is enough to validate fit before paying. Make also offers a free tier.
Can I migrate from Make to Asana?
Yes, but there is no universal one-click importer between these products. Export records from Make as CSV where available, map fields into the Asana data model, rebuild automations and permissions manually, and run both systems in parallel for one full reporting cycle. Asana exposes a public API and 300+ integrations, which makes a scripted migration practical.
Which tool is better for operations and programme teams managing cross-team portfolios?
Asana is purpose-built for that use case: best-in-class goal-to-task alignment and portfolio visibility. Its main trade-off is that no native time tracking and limited built-in docs. Make counters with visual canvas makes routers, iterators and error handlers intuitive, but smaller app directory than zapier. If your priority matches the Asana strengths above, it is the more direct fit.